Jump to: navigation, search

Talk:Panagia of Tinos

517 bytes removed, 00:32, February 25, 2008
no edit summary
This article is confusing. What is it about? Is the article about a saint, an icon, travel itinery, church, festival. etc? It is not encyclopedic! It appears to be mainly an article about an icon. Thus, it should be edited as an icon article and the parts about the church should be in a separate article, and the travel information omitted and left to the external travel links. [[User:Wsk|Wsk]] 12:12, February 24, 2008 (PST)
 :This article Its about the WHOLE PACKAGE! Panagia TINOS is probably confusing you because you are looking at it through the eyes of an Editor only whole package ...I think if you spend tooo much time in here you end the walk up 'boxing' information too much. Everyone who knows this place/the hill, the church/icon know its one and the same thing - its INTERWOVENicon. It HAS to be addressed as one article '''Sorry if I am grumpy but I just am today'''.This OrthoWiki is an editing tool so we can assist EACH OTHER.. you cant talk Its not about the icon without talking about the church history picking up every fault that a person contributing might have ... they are so closely linked even to this very day is just not fair ...secondwe dont all have the same skills and as such, IMO its if I have contributed an article that is not perfect fix it up to a travel guidebetter standard. If you go to the 'travel guide' links they have descriptions about the church/icon history -- [[User:Ixthis888|Vasiliki]] 16:32, February 24, 2008 (which are sources of informationPST). There is nothing wrong with describing the road that leads up to the church:PS, thanks Pistevo for modifying it makes the article more interesting and I have AN Encyclopedia at home and when you go to articles on places they have descriptive information ...there does not seem to be anything wrong with thatmore encyclopedic? This is all part of the information about that place and that icon. If you hate it ...delete it ... dont be so critical about something though that people have volunteered their time and effort into preparing. -- [[User:Ixthis888|Vasiliki]] 1316:1432, February 24, 2008 (PST)

Navigation menu