Talk:Liturgical books

From OrthodoxWiki
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Talk:Liturgical books of the Orthodox Church moved to Talk:Liturgical books)
m (de-link)
 
(5 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
I would like to suggest that the name of this article be changed to "Liturgical Books, Byzantine." It's clear that the author of the article was referring to the Byzantine tradition (represented by both Greek and Slavic Orthodoxy). There are a number of other Orthodox traditions, however, each with its own liturgical books. I am thinking here of the Coptic, Armenian, Ethiopian, etc. -- [[Fr Lev]]
+
I would like to suggest that the name of this article be changed to "Liturgical Books, Byzantine." It's clear that the author of the article was referring to the Byzantine tradition (represented by both Greek and Slavic Orthodoxy). There are a number of other Orthodox traditions, however, each with its own liturgical books. I am thinking here of the Coptic, Armenian, Ethiopian, etc. -- Fr Lev
  
 
:I admit a large amount of ignorance in this area and honestly created the article so I could learn more from everyone else. I am very open to the name of this article changing. What does everyone else think? Oh, I was thinking of making a template to basically point any new persons looking into liturgics in the right places. What do y'all think? [[User:Joe Rodgers|Joe]] 20050109
 
:I admit a large amount of ignorance in this area and honestly created the article so I could learn more from everyone else. I am very open to the name of this article changing. What does everyone else think? Oh, I was thinking of making a template to basically point any new persons looking into liturgics in the right places. What do y'all think? [[User:Joe Rodgers|Joe]] 20050109
  
: The Byzantine (incl. both Slavic and Greek) tradition is sort of a "default" for OrthodoxWiki, and non-Byzantine articles which might otherwise have the same name as Byzantine ones are specified with a parenthetical in the title.  See [[OW:MOS]], which indicates, among other things, such specifications as [[Vespers (Western Rite)]] or [[Church of Alexandria (Coptic)]].
+
: The Byzantine (incl. both Slavic and Greek) tradition is sort of a "default" for OrthodoxWiki, and non-Byzantine articles which might otherwise have the same name as Byzantine ones are specified with a parenthetical in the title.  See [[OW:SM]], which indicates, among other things, such specifications as [[Vespers (Western Rite)]] or [[Church of Alexandria (Coptic)]].
  
 
: I'm of the opinion that this article ought to be named simply [[Liturgical books]] or even [[List of liturgical books]] (since the article is not likely to be much more than that?).  "Of the Orthodox Church" is pretty much implied by inclusion on this site, I would think.  {{User:ASDamick/sig}} 15:37, January 9, 2006 (CST)
 
: I'm of the opinion that this article ought to be named simply [[Liturgical books]] or even [[List of liturgical books]] (since the article is not likely to be much more than that?).  "Of the Orthodox Church" is pretty much implied by inclusion on this site, I would think.  {{User:ASDamick/sig}} 15:37, January 9, 2006 (CST)
  
::I agree about the default and the renaming. I'm moving the page to "Liturgical books" - we can go from there. [[User:FrJohn|Fr. John]]
+
::I agree about the default and the renaming. I'm moving the page to "Liturgical books" since I hope this will be more of an overview rather than a simple list. [[User:FrJohn|Fr. John]]
 +
 
 +
== Redundant Articles ==
 +
 
 +
Many of the books described in this article already have articles in their own right, some more extensive than others (e.g., [[Apostolos]], [[Menaion]], [[Octoechos]], [[Pentecostarion]], [[Lenten Triodion]], [[Psalter]], [[Typikon]], although this final one has no content).  {{User:Dcndavid/sig}} 15:38, January 10, 2006 (CST)
 +
 
 +
:That's a good point. Maybe this page can be a kind of disambiguation or summary page, linking to the others and providing a general overview. [[User:FrJohn|Fr. John]]
 +
 
 +
::I don't know if this was conveyed, but I envisioned this turning into a template eventually, I just wanted to get the ball rolling. [[User:Joe Rodgers|Joe]] 20060110

Latest revision as of 17:44, November 8, 2012

I would like to suggest that the name of this article be changed to "Liturgical Books, Byzantine." It's clear that the author of the article was referring to the Byzantine tradition (represented by both Greek and Slavic Orthodoxy). There are a number of other Orthodox traditions, however, each with its own liturgical books. I am thinking here of the Coptic, Armenian, Ethiopian, etc. -- Fr Lev

I admit a large amount of ignorance in this area and honestly created the article so I could learn more from everyone else. I am very open to the name of this article changing. What does everyone else think? Oh, I was thinking of making a template to basically point any new persons looking into liturgics in the right places. What do y'all think? Joe 20050109
The Byzantine (incl. both Slavic and Greek) tradition is sort of a "default" for OrthodoxWiki, and non-Byzantine articles which might otherwise have the same name as Byzantine ones are specified with a parenthetical in the title. See OW:SM, which indicates, among other things, such specifications as Vespers (Western Rite) or Church of Alexandria (Coptic).
I'm of the opinion that this article ought to be named simply Liturgical books or even List of liturgical books (since the article is not likely to be much more than that?). "Of the Orthodox Church" is pretty much implied by inclusion on this site, I would think. —Fr. Andrew talk contribs (THINK!) 15:37, January 9, 2006 (CST)
I agree about the default and the renaming. I'm moving the page to "Liturgical books" since I hope this will be more of an overview rather than a simple list. Fr. John

Redundant Articles

Many of the books described in this article already have articles in their own right, some more extensive than others (e.g., Apostolos, Menaion, Octoechos, Pentecostarion, Lenten Triodion, Psalter, Typikon, although this final one has no content). —Dcn. David talk contribs 15:38, January 10, 2006 (CST)

That's a good point. Maybe this page can be a kind of disambiguation or summary page, linking to the others and providing a general overview. Fr. John
I don't know if this was conveyed, but I envisioned this turning into a template eventually, I just wanted to get the ball rolling. Joe 20060110
Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
Navigation
interaction
Donate

Please consider supporting OrthodoxWiki. FAQs

Toolbox