Difference between revisions of "Talk:Gregory the Dialogist"
(New page: ==Including the "Liturgy of St Gregory the Great" on this link== I am stating this here, because I do not want to start an edit-war. The Liturgy of St Gregory the Great was revised by St...) |
m (→Including the "Liturgy of St Gregory the Great" on this link) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
I am stating this here, because I do not want to start an edit-war. | I am stating this here, because I do not want to start an edit-war. | ||
| − | The Liturgy of St Gregory the Great was revised by St Gregory and those revisions are reflected in pre-schismatic usages. The Tridentine Mass is essentially a heavy revision of the Gregorian Liturgy, and Willibrord is fully aware of this, based on his previous edit wars. I would suggest that you could say that the Gregorian Mass forms the *basis* of the AWRV's "Liturgy of St Gregory the Great" (which is primarily-- and no one denies this-- an edited Tridentine Mass, but to imply that the two are one and the same is intellectually dishonest. | + | The Liturgy of St Gregory the Great was revised by St Gregory and those revisions are reflected in pre-schismatic usages. The Tridentine Mass is essentially a heavy revision of the Gregorian Liturgy, and Willibrord is fully aware of this, based on his previous edit wars. I would suggest that you could say that the Gregorian Mass forms the *basis* of the AWRV's "Liturgy of St Gregory the Great" (which is primarily-- and no one denies this-- an edited Tridentine Mass), but to imply that the two are one and the same is intellectually dishonest. |
I am not saying that this is not a good or proper liturgy, as you may assume-- it's not perfect, but it is certainly better than the "Liturgy of St Tikhon". However, it is NOT the liturgy St Gregory authored.--[[User:JosephSuaiden|JosephSuaiden]] 18:34, August 23, 2008 (UTC) | I am not saying that this is not a good or proper liturgy, as you may assume-- it's not perfect, but it is certainly better than the "Liturgy of St Tikhon". However, it is NOT the liturgy St Gregory authored.--[[User:JosephSuaiden|JosephSuaiden]] 18:34, August 23, 2008 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 18:37, August 23, 2008
Including the "Liturgy of St Gregory the Great" on this link
I am stating this here, because I do not want to start an edit-war.
The Liturgy of St Gregory the Great was revised by St Gregory and those revisions are reflected in pre-schismatic usages. The Tridentine Mass is essentially a heavy revision of the Gregorian Liturgy, and Willibrord is fully aware of this, based on his previous edit wars. I would suggest that you could say that the Gregorian Mass forms the *basis* of the AWRV's "Liturgy of St Gregory the Great" (which is primarily-- and no one denies this-- an edited Tridentine Mass), but to imply that the two are one and the same is intellectually dishonest.
I am not saying that this is not a good or proper liturgy, as you may assume-- it's not perfect, but it is certainly better than the "Liturgy of St Tikhon". However, it is NOT the liturgy St Gregory authored.--JosephSuaiden 18:34, August 23, 2008 (UTC)
