OrthodoxWiki talk:Style Manual

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
m
(Using "Saint" with saint names)
Line 4: Line 4:
 
:That can be taken care of in the body of the article.  Not only would it mess with alphabetization and searching to have every article name for a saint start with "saint," but there would also be potential issues with regard to which form we use:  '''Saint''', '''St.''', '''St''', '''S.''' or '''S''' (all are currently in use in English convention).  Additionally, there are potential quibbles over which persons are considered saints or not ('''Augustine of Hippo''', '''Saint Augustine of Hippo''', or '''Blessed Augustine of Hippo''').  Not using "saint" for article titles also means that moving articles will be lessened should a person already with an article be declared a saint.  The note can simply be made in the article body.  --[[User:ASDamick|Rdr. Andrew]]
 
:That can be taken care of in the body of the article.  Not only would it mess with alphabetization and searching to have every article name for a saint start with "saint," but there would also be potential issues with regard to which form we use:  '''Saint''', '''St.''', '''St''', '''S.''' or '''S''' (all are currently in use in English convention).  Additionally, there are potential quibbles over which persons are considered saints or not ('''Augustine of Hippo''', '''Saint Augustine of Hippo''', or '''Blessed Augustine of Hippo''').  Not using "saint" for article titles also means that moving articles will be lessened should a person already with an article be declared a saint.  The note can simply be made in the article body.  --[[User:ASDamick|Rdr. Andrew]]
  
 +
:Agreed with respect to article names. However, within articles, we should probably determine a standard way of doing this. Using "Saint" or "St." for every single instance of a saint's name (for example, in an article on that saint) seems a bit over the top. Perhaps the first time a saint's name is used within an article? Also, should it be spelled out or abbreviated? I recommend spelled out, since that cuts down on the argument factor and also is more professional. —[[User:Basil|Basil]]
  
 
== "Catholic" Churches==
 
== "Catholic" Churches==

Revision as of 21:54, January 8, 2005

Using "Saint" with saint names

Since we are all Orthodox here, should we not always refer to Saints with the word Saint proceding their name? I think it would be proper. 208.57.98.20 11:03, 23 Dec 2004 (CST)

That can be taken care of in the body of the article. Not only would it mess with alphabetization and searching to have every article name for a saint start with "saint," but there would also be potential issues with regard to which form we use: Saint, St., St, S. or S (all are currently in use in English convention). Additionally, there are potential quibbles over which persons are considered saints or not (Augustine of Hippo, Saint Augustine of Hippo, or Blessed Augustine of Hippo). Not using "saint" for article titles also means that moving articles will be lessened should a person already with an article be declared a saint. The note can simply be made in the article body. --Rdr. Andrew
Agreed with respect to article names. However, within articles, we should probably determine a standard way of doing this. Using "Saint" or "St." for every single instance of a saint's name (for example, in an article on that saint) seems a bit over the top. Perhaps the first time a saint's name is used within an article? Also, should it be spelled out or abbreviated? I recommend spelled out, since that cuts down on the argument factor and also is more professional. —Basil

"Catholic" Churches

Surely in an Orthodox context RC churches should be designated "Roman Catholic" and not simply "Catholic"?

In most cases, that is the protocol being used. However, especially when referring to some of the smaller bodies within the RCC, referring to them as (e.g.) the Syrian Roman Catholic Church (rather than simply Syrian Catholic Church) could be misleading -- for one thing, most Eastern Rite (Roman) Catholics explicitly do not use Roman to describe themselves. Further, the use of Roman in those cases might mislead one to think that such churches were using the Latin Rite, which most are not. The relevant articles will certainly make explicit that such churches are subject to the Vatican. --Rdr. Andrew

Excellent work Reader Andrew! Thanks, FrJohn 23:27, 2 Jan 2005 (CST)

Personal tools
Variants
Actions
Navigation
interaction
Donate

Please consider supporting OrthodoxWiki. FAQs

Toolbox