John S. Romanides

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(Some expansion...)
m (link)
(42 intermediate revisions by 13 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Father '''John S. Romanides''' (1927 - 2001) was a prominent 20th century Orthodox Christian [[priest]], [[theologian]], and writer.  
+
[[File:John-romanides.jpg|right|thumb|px225|Rev. Prof. John S. Romanides]]
 +
Father '''John Savvas Romanides''' (1927 - 2001) was a prominent 20th century Orthodox Christian [[priest]], [[theologian]], and writer. Fr. Romanides served under the [[Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America]] and the [[Church of Greece]].
  
 
==Life==
 
==Life==
Fr. Romanides was ordained in 1951 while studying at Yale University Divinity School, and served at Holy Trinity Church in Waterbury, Connecticut, from 1951 till 1954. After finishing his studies at Yale he was transferred for the summer of 1954 to Holy Trinity Cathedral in New York City until he left for studies at St. Sergius Orthodox Theological School in Paris (1954-55). He did his doctoral work at the University of Athens from 1956 to 1957. He was appointed professor at Holy Cross, Brookline, Mass. where he taught between 1957 and 1965 while continuing his studies and research at the Harvard Divinity School and then at the Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences. All this time, between 1957 to 1968, he was also a parish priest. He was appointed to the parish of Newport, New Hampshire in 1958. Then in 1959 he was appointed the first priest of St. Athanasius The Great Orthodox Church in Arlington, Mass. which he helped found and organize. He resigned from Holy Cross in 1965 in protest over the removal of Father Georges Florovsky from the faculty by Archbishop Iacovos. Between 1965 and 1968 Father Romanides served as the pastor of Holy Apostles' Parish in Haverhill, Mass. He was professor of dogmatics at the University of Thessalonike from 1970 until his retirement in 1984. From 1970 on, he also taught at the University of Balamand in Lebanon. He continued to teach even after his retirement.
+
Fr. Romanides was [[ordination|ordained]] in 1951 while studying at Yale University Divinity School, and served at Holy Trinity Church in Waterbury, Connecticut, from 1951 till 1954. After finishing his studies at Yale he was transferred for the summer of 1954 to Holy Trinity Cathedral in New York City until he left for studies at [[St. Sergius Orthodox Theological Institute (Paris, France)|St. Sergius Orthodox Theological Institute]] in Paris (1954-55). He did his doctoral work at the University of Athens from 1956 to 1957. His dissertation, ''The Ancestral Sin'', was accepted and published in 1957, but over the objections of faculty members [[Panagiotes N. Trembelas|Panagiotes Trembelas]] and P. I. Bratsiotis. Although the dissertation focused on original sin, [[Christos Yannaras]] writes, "Romanides succeeded in summarizing the whole of Orthodox [[dogma]], emphasizing the deep gulf separating it from the intellectualist and juridical expressions of Western dogma".<ref>Christos Yannaras, ''Orthodoxy and the West'', p. 276 (ISBN 978-1885652812)</ref>
  
He also represented the Church of Greece as member of the Central Committee of the World Council of Churches and in the dialogues with the Lutherans and the Oriental Orthodox.
+
He was appointed professor at [[Holy Cross Greek Orthodox School of Theology (Brookline, Massachusetts)|Holy Cross]], Brookline, Massachusetts, where he taught between 1957 and 1965 while continuing his studies and research at the Harvard Divinity School and then at the Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences. All this time, between 1957 to 1968, he was also a [[parish]] priest. He was appointed to the parish of Newport, New Hampshire, in 1958. Then in 1959 he was appointed the first priest of St. Athanasius the Great Orthodox Church in Arlington, Massachusetts, which he helped found and organize. He resigned from Holy Cross in 1965 in protest over the removal of Father [[Georges Florovsky]] from the faculty by [[Archbishop]] [[Iakovos (Coucouzis) of America|Iakovos]]. Between 1965 and 1968 Father Romanides served as the pastor of Holy Apostles' Parish in Haverhill, Massachusetts. He was professor of [[dogmatics]] at the University of Thessalonike from 1970 until his resignation in 1982. From 1970 on, he also taught at the University of Balamand in Lebanon. He continued to teach even after his retirement. He reposed in Athens on [[November 1]], 2001.  
  
His legacy lives on through his more then 2,000 students, including many priests, monks, and at least 10 bishops.
+
He also represented the [[Church of Greece]] as member of the Central Committee of the [[World Council of Churches]] and in the dialogues with the Lutherans and the Oriental Orthodox.
 +
 
 +
His legacy lives on through his more then 2,000 students, including many priests, [[monk]]s, and at least 10 bishops.
  
 
== Works ==
 
== Works ==
Romanides argued for the existence of "national, cultural and even linguistic unity between East and West Romans" until the intrusion and takeover of the West Romans (the Roman Catholics) by the Franks (German tribes).
+
Romanides argued for the existence of a "national, cultural and even linguistic unity between Eastern and Western Romans" that exisited until the intrusion and takeover of the West Romans (the [[Roman Catholic Church|Roman Catholics]]) by the Franks and or Goths (German tribes).
  
{{stub}}
+
*''The Ecclesiology of St Ignatius of Antioch'' (1956).
 +
* ''Franks, Romans, Feudalism, and Doctrine: An Interplay Between Theology and Society'' (1982) ISBN 0916586545
 +
* ''Ancestral Sin'' (2002) ISBN 0970730314
 +
* ''An Outline of Orthodox Patristic Dogmatics'', edited by [[George Dragas|George Dion Dragas]]. (2004) ISBN 0974561843
 +
* ''The Life in Christ'', translated from the French with an introduction by James L. Kelley (2010) ISBN 919672752
  
* ''Franks, Romans, Feudalism, and Doctrine: An Interplay Between Theology and Society'' (1982)
+
==Studies==
*''Ancestral Sin'' (2002)
+
*Aidan Nichols. "John Romanides and neo-Photianism," in ''Light From the East: Authors and Themes in Orthodox Theology.'' 1995. ISBN 0722050801
* ''An Outline of Orthodox Patristic Dogmatics'' (2004)
+
*Andrew J. Sopko. ''Prophet of Roman Orthodoxy: The Theology of John Romanides.'' 1998. ISBN 978-0919672253
 +
*James L. Kelley. ''A Realism of Glory: Lectures on Christology in the Works of Protopresbyter John Romanides.'' Rollinsford, NH: Orthodox Research Institute, 2009. ISBN 9781933275376
  
==Criticism==
+
==References==
Some of the criticisms have been raised against:
+
<references />
 
+
* The Franks were among the earliest converts to the
+
Orthodox faith (well, so were the Burgundians, but they were absorbed by
+
the Frankish kingdom), so they could hardly be accused of persecuting
+
"Roman Catholics" (which is misleading terminology in itself at this
+
period);
+
* Clovis himself converted to Orthodoxy, as did his Frankish
+
subjects.  Indeed, the ecclesiastical hierarchy in Visigothic Gaul openly
+
worked on behalf of Clovis, since the bishops preferred the Orthodox
+
Franks to the heretical Arian Visigoths.  Far from regarding Clovis as an
+
anti-imperial barbarian, the Eastern Emperor Anastasius (reigned 491-519)
+
granted Clovis the highest honors normally granted to distinguished
+
senators in Constantinople -- the coveted ranks of consul and patrician
+
in 508.  As J.M. Wallace-Hadrill, no blind admirer of Clovis, put it in
+
his *The Barbarian West* (N.Y.: Harper Torchbooks, 1962), page 74-75,
+
"the Emperor had for some time been in touch with the Franks and was glad
+
to recognize them, at the appropriate moment, as a counter-balance to
+
Gothic power in the West."  From this point on, the Eastern Empire and
+
the Frankish Kingdom were usually allies pitted against the Arian
+
barbarian kingdoms in the West.  The Papacy too smiled on the Franks as
+
protectors of the true faith, and called upon the later Carolingian
+
dynasty to protect Rome from the Lombards when the Byzantine
+
administration in central Italy collapsed in the early 8th century.
+
 
+
Relations began to sour when Pepin "the Short" handed what had
+
been the Exarchate of Ravenna over to the Pope as the nucleus of the
+
Papal States (at that time, the "Patrimony of St. Peter").  But as the
+
Byzantines had lost that area to the Lombards, who in turn lost it to
+
Pepin, it was his by right of conquest, and the Roman claims were
+
admittedly weak.  Later, Charlemagne had a brief border war with the
+
Eastern Empire, but this was to force his fellow emperor in
+
Constantinople to recognize Charlemagne's comparable position in the
+
West. 
+
 
+
* There never was any Carolingian "conspiracy" to overrun the
+
Eastern Empire.  (This issue has been discussed at length on the Byzans-L listhost)
+
 
+
* Professor Romanides and his followers appear to confuse the Greek
+
usage of "Franks" -- which later writers applied indiscriminately to
+
_all_ Western Latin Europeans, including Germans! -- with the original
+
tribe that occupied Gaul.  Yes, the sack of Constantinople in 1204, an
+
event which almost everyone on this list deplores as one of the most
+
short-sighted tragedies of history, was carried out by "Frankish" (i.e.,
+
French) minor nobility, but let's not forget the Venetians (Italians!)
+
either.  The Great Schism of 1054, which split the Latin and Greek
+
churches apart, was carried out during the pontificate of Leo IX -- a
+
German, not a "Frank."  Professor Romanides, either through ignorance of
+
Western history or perhaps because he has an axe to grind, has blamed the
+
poor "Franks" of the Merovingian and Carolingian states for the excesses
+
of later people who might not have recognized nor used that name.
+
 
+
Also, Justinian was issuing his *Novellae* in Greek, not Latin,
+
throughout his reign, because Latin was becoming a forgotten language in
+
the East, just as Greek was vanishing in the West -- which makes claims
+
of a prevailing linguistic and cultural continuity questionable at best.
+
  
 
==Sources==
 
==Sources==
* [http://www.romanity.org/mir/me02en.htm Fabrications about Prof. John S. Romanides by Capuchino Priest Ianni Spiteri] - A response to Yannis Spiteris, ''La teologia ortodossa neo-greca'' (Bologna, Italy: [www.dehoniane.it Edizioni Dehoniane], 1992) 281-295.
+
*Christos Yannaras, ''Orthodoxy and the West: Hellenic Self-Identity in the Modern Age'' (2006). ISBN 978-1885652812
* [http://www.uni-heidelberg.de/subject/hd/fak7/hist/o1/logs/byzans-l/log.started960829/0031.html Re: Fr. John Romanides' writings on history and eccesiology] - A response on the Byzans-L email list by Timothy Bratton
+
* [http://www.romanity.org/mir/me02en.htm Fabrications about Prof. John S. Romanides by Capuchino Priest Ianni Spiteri] - A response to Yannis Spiteris, ''La teologia ortodossa neo-greca'' (Bologna, Italy: [http://www.dehoniane.it Edizioni Dehoniane], 1992) 281-295.
 +
<!---* [http://www.uni-heidelberg.de/subject/hd/fak7/hist/o1/logs/byzans-l/log.started960829/0031.html Re: Fr. John Romanides' writings on history and eccesiology] - A response on the [http://www.doaks.org/byzansl.html Byzans-L email list] by Timothy Bratton --->
  
== External links ==
+
==External links==
* [http://www.romanity.org/ The Romans: Ancient, Medieval and Modern] Website honoring Fr. John and archiving many of his writings (and those of others)
+
*[http://www.romanity.org/ The Romans: Ancient, Medieval and Modern] Website honoring Fr. John and archiving many of his writings (and those of others)
 +
* Φιλολόγικα/Philologica (one blog by Hans-Georg Lundahl): [http://filolohika.blogspot.fr/2012/03/is-romanides-accurate.html "Is Romanides accurate?"]
 +
* Φιλολόγικα/Philologica: [http://filolohika.blogspot.fr/2012/03/was-romanides-accurate-bis-not-very.html "Was Romanides accurate? Bis! Not very much at all!"]
 +
* Φιλολόγικα/Philologica: [http://filolohika.blogspot.fr/2012/03/linguistics-for-romanides-greek-latin.html "Linguistics for Romanides: Greek, Latin, Patois"]
 +
*[http://www.photooikoumene.org/photo.nsf/htmllist/3DD32B7A81779631C1256C63005AD166/&#36;FILE/07165-24t.jpg Photo] ([http://www.photooikoumene.org/photo.nsf/htmllist/A07165-24.html high-resolution version]): Rev. Prof. John S. ROMANIDES (Greece), Church of Greece, member of the WCC Central Committee, elected by the WCC 8th Assembly, Harare, [[Zimbabwe]], December 1998 (JPEG; © PhotoOikoumene, World Council of Churches, Geneva, Switzerland)
  
 +
[[Category:Modern Writers]]
 +
[[Category:Priests]]
  
{{stub}}
+
[[el:Ιωάννης Ρωμανίδης]]
 
+
 
+
[[Category:Modern Writers]]
+

Revision as of 17:56, January 16, 2013

Rev. Prof. John S. Romanides

Father John Savvas Romanides (1927 - 2001) was a prominent 20th century Orthodox Christian priest, theologian, and writer. Fr. Romanides served under the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America and the Church of Greece.

Contents

Life

Fr. Romanides was ordained in 1951 while studying at Yale University Divinity School, and served at Holy Trinity Church in Waterbury, Connecticut, from 1951 till 1954. After finishing his studies at Yale he was transferred for the summer of 1954 to Holy Trinity Cathedral in New York City until he left for studies at St. Sergius Orthodox Theological Institute in Paris (1954-55). He did his doctoral work at the University of Athens from 1956 to 1957. His dissertation, The Ancestral Sin, was accepted and published in 1957, but over the objections of faculty members Panagiotes Trembelas and P. I. Bratsiotis. Although the dissertation focused on original sin, Christos Yannaras writes, "Romanides succeeded in summarizing the whole of Orthodox dogma, emphasizing the deep gulf separating it from the intellectualist and juridical expressions of Western dogma".[1]

He was appointed professor at Holy Cross, Brookline, Massachusetts, where he taught between 1957 and 1965 while continuing his studies and research at the Harvard Divinity School and then at the Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences. All this time, between 1957 to 1968, he was also a parish priest. He was appointed to the parish of Newport, New Hampshire, in 1958. Then in 1959 he was appointed the first priest of St. Athanasius the Great Orthodox Church in Arlington, Massachusetts, which he helped found and organize. He resigned from Holy Cross in 1965 in protest over the removal of Father Georges Florovsky from the faculty by Archbishop Iakovos. Between 1965 and 1968 Father Romanides served as the pastor of Holy Apostles' Parish in Haverhill, Massachusetts. He was professor of dogmatics at the University of Thessalonike from 1970 until his resignation in 1982. From 1970 on, he also taught at the University of Balamand in Lebanon. He continued to teach even after his retirement. He reposed in Athens on November 1, 2001.

He also represented the Church of Greece as member of the Central Committee of the World Council of Churches and in the dialogues with the Lutherans and the Oriental Orthodox.

His legacy lives on through his more then 2,000 students, including many priests, monks, and at least 10 bishops.

Works

Romanides argued for the existence of a "national, cultural and even linguistic unity between Eastern and Western Romans" that exisited until the intrusion and takeover of the West Romans (the Roman Catholics) by the Franks and or Goths (German tribes).

  • The Ecclesiology of St Ignatius of Antioch (1956).
  • Franks, Romans, Feudalism, and Doctrine: An Interplay Between Theology and Society (1982) ISBN 0916586545
  • Ancestral Sin (2002) ISBN 0970730314
  • An Outline of Orthodox Patristic Dogmatics, edited by George Dion Dragas. (2004) ISBN 0974561843
  • The Life in Christ, translated from the French with an introduction by James L. Kelley (2010) ISBN 919672752

Studies

  • Aidan Nichols. "John Romanides and neo-Photianism," in Light From the East: Authors and Themes in Orthodox Theology. 1995. ISBN 0722050801
  • Andrew J. Sopko. Prophet of Roman Orthodoxy: The Theology of John Romanides. 1998. ISBN 978-0919672253
  • James L. Kelley. A Realism of Glory: Lectures on Christology in the Works of Protopresbyter John Romanides. Rollinsford, NH: Orthodox Research Institute, 2009. ISBN 9781933275376

References

  1. Christos Yannaras, Orthodoxy and the West, p. 276 (ISBN 978-1885652812)

Sources

External links

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
Navigation
interaction
Donate

Please consider supporting OrthodoxWiki. FAQs

Toolbox
In other languages